Home » Blogs » Low Commission Realtors and Agents: What’s the Catch

Low Commission Realtors and Agents: What’s the Catch

When you search for ways to keep more of your home sale profits, low commission realtors seem like an attractive shortcut. But before you jump in, it’s vital to ask: why are they cheaper, and what trade-offs might you face in 2025?


Summary
“The intro highlights that while low commission realtors are appealing cost-wise, understanding the trade-offs is essential.”

What Is the Current Average Realtor Commission in 2025?

In 2025, the average combined commission for listing and buying agents ranges between 5.4% to 5.6% of the sale price. Clever’s April 2025 survey and other national analytics show an average of 5.44%.

Some sources suggest a nationwide span of 5–6%, with the listing agent receiving around half. In Texas, the average hit 5.76% as of late 2024.


Summary
“This paragraph defines the 2025 baseline for realtor fees, using data from Clever and others.”

What Counts as “Low” for Low Commission Realtors?

Low commission realtors typically charge 1% to 1.5% for the listing agent role, significantly below the traditional norms . They may also offer flat-fee structures—say, a fixed $3,000 to $5,000 for listing on MLS—rather than charging a percentage of the sale price .


Summary
“Clarifies what counts as low commissions—typically 1–1.5% or flat-fee models.”

You can read our more articles on different topics here:

Why Are Low Commission Realtors Cheaper—What’s the Catch?

While saving is appealing, low commission realtors may deliver less hands-on support. With reduced earnings, they often rely on higher volume, potentially diminishing attention to your sale . They may skip services like professional staging, extensive marketing, or open houses. Flat-fee agents, in particular, might just list your property on the MLS without extra layers of service.


Summary
“Explains service trade-offs: less attention and fewer premium services.”

What Has Changed in Realtor Commission Regulations?

Since the August 2024 settlement with the National Association of Realtors, commissions have become fully negotiable—no fixed norms.

This gives sellers leverage to seek low commission realtors or negotiate lower fees. Industry data shows consumers increasingly embracing rebates, flat-fee brokers, and hybrid models to cut costs.


Summary
“Describes regulatory changes that enable negotiation and prominence of low-fee models.”

Are Low Commission Realtors Worth It?

On a $500,000 home sale, the average total commission (5–6%) could be $25,000–$30,000. A low commission realtor charging 1.5% might cost just $7,500—a potential saving of $17,500–$22,500. But if fewer marketing efforts result in a lower sale price, these savings can shrink—or vanish.


Summary
“Demonstrates the potential monetary benefit, tempered by possible reduced sale outcomes.”

How Is Your Home Sale Price Affected by Using Low Commission Realtors?

Lower exposure due to fewer marketing resources might yield fewer offers or lower bids. Without market-savvy pricing and negotiation, your final sale figure could underperform. Conversely, savvy sellers in hot markets may still command strong prices with minimal guidance if they’re experienced.


Summary
“Analyzes the pricing and exposure risk of using low commission realtors.”

Can You Negotiate a Traditional Agent’s Commission Instead?

Absolutely. REALTOR commissions are negotiable. Many sellers secured lower-than-average rates, particularly for high-value homes or repeat business. 

Traditional agents provide comprehensive services such as staging, marketing, counteroffer negotiation, and inspection handling—services that justify their fees.

 
Summary
“Describes the negotiation pathway and value of full-service traditional agents.”

Should You Consider Flat-Fee or Hybrid Models Instead?

Flat-fee models typically charge a set amount (e.g., $5,000) regardless of sale price. These provide predictability and cost savings but may limit support. Hybrid or technology-based alternatives (like startups Galleon, Listwise, Ridley, Turbohome) offer varied options—FSBO support, agent bidding, AI assistance—that may balance cost and service.


Summary
“Explores flat-fee and hybrid startup alternatives—cost-effective but with trade-offs.”

What Are the Tax Implications of Realtor Commission?

Under U.S. tax law, realtor commissions are not deductible by the seller—they reduce the home’s sales proceeds which may impact capital gain calculations.

However, the Home Sale Gain Exclusion allows individuals to exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for married couples) from taxation when selling their primary residence. 

For those using part of their home for business, deductible portions of real estate taxes and depreciation may apply—see IRS Publication 530 for real estate tax deductions and Publication 946 for depreciation rules.


Summary
“Explains 2025 tax context: commissions reduce gain; gain exclusion applies; cites IRS sources.”

Alternatives Beyond Low Commission Realtors

  • For Sale By Owner (FSBO): No listing agent fees—but you shoulder all marketing, negotiation, legal complexity.
  • iBuyers/Home-buying companies: Sell fast for a fee, often below market value. Evaluate net proceeds carefully.
  • Commission rebates: Some buyer agents offer rebates post-sale, returning part of their fee to you. 

    Summary“Outlines other seller paths—FSBO, iBuyers, rebates—with pros and cons.”

How to Choose the Right Path for You

  1. Define your priorities—max sale price, speed, ease, or cost savings.
  2. Interview multiple agents: ask about commission models, services, experience, and local knowledge.
  3. Compare estimated net proceeds across models—traditional vs low-commission vs flat-fee vs iBuyer.
  4. Verify the commission structure in writing and confirm what each agent will handle.
  5. Consult IRS resources directly for accurate tax guidance:

    • IRS Publication 523 (Home Sale Gain Exclusion)
    • IRS Publication 530 (Homeowner Tax Deductions)
    • IRS Publication 946 (Depreciation for Tax Year 2025) 

      Summary“Provides actionable steps for sellers and offers IRS links as credible resources.”

Final Thoughts

Low commission realtors can save big, but not without trade-offs—especially in service levels or sale outcomes. With commission rules now negotiable and plenty of alternative models available, doing your homework is essential.

Factor in market conditions, tax implications, and your own capacity to manage the process. Be transparent, compare carefully, and choose what aligns best with your financial and personal goals.


Summary
“Summarizes that low commission realtors have pros and cons and encourages informed decision-making.”

Disclaimer: The tools and content on USATaxCalculator.com are for informational purposes only and do not constitute tax or financial advice. Our calculators provide basic estimates and may not reflect the latest tax laws.

We recommend consulting a certified tax professional or the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) for accurate guidance. USATaxCalculator.com is not responsible for any decisions made based on the information provided.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top